I’m no hypocrite

Last night I got accused of being a hypocrite. What caused this libellous accusation? A picture I re-tweeted.

Greater Sydney Rams tweet_Tom Hill

Offending Tweet?

Now I ask you, what is wrong with this picture?

Nothing, I say. A young bloke presenting the kit for one of the new National Rugby Championship (NRC) teams, The Greater Sydney Rams. Is it my fault that the alternate shirt they brought to the photo session didn’t fit young Mr Tom Hill?

(By the way Tom, I am single. Love rugby. Cook a mean mud cake and am pretty good at massages. So I have been told. #JustSayin)

Now I also favourited another Rams tweet staring another young man call Ben Vola Vola. But my noticing of this particular tweet didn’t receive the condemnation of my promotion Mr Hill’s.

Greater Sydney Rams tweet_Ben Vola

The other tweet

Was it because I drew more attention to one than I did the other?

Was it because my reply to the “Tom Hill” tweet was :

Steph Batt's Twitter reply to Greater Sydney Rams

How do you know that I was not referring to all of the social media interactions that The Greater Sydney Rams have had with their fans and the wider world?

Ok, so that last question was rhetorical……but I do have to say that from my point of view the Rams have done well with their social media campaign to date.

Frequently when I make a comment about the ‘form’ of a rugby player I get labelled with the ‘hypocrite’ tag. Sometimes tongue in check. Other times not. So am I? Do I need to take a good long look at myself in the mirror and accept that, when it comes to half naked photos of athletes, I am in fact a card carrying hypocrite?

I would disagree. I will admit to at times making comments regarding some of said pictures to promote debate and discussion.

The biggest point that I struggle to get across in these discussions is that in a lot of cases pictures of female athletes, clothed or otherwise, are sexualised in an inappropriate manner.

What is the difference I hear you ask? Well……

Appropriate – Oxford Womens’ Rugby nude calendar raising money for a good cause.

Oxford Womens' Rugby calendar image

Oxford Womens’ Rugby calendar image

Inappropriate – Imagine a mechanic’s workshop calendar……. Or perhaps Lingerie Football……

Lingerie Football

Lingerie Football

So what is the difference….. Well who in their right mind would play a contact sport in their underwear, complete with garter? Why don’t male American Football players play in their underwear?

You want another example?

This is Christina Vukicevic, a Norwegian hurdler. Look at the poses. Are they saying “I am a finely tuned athlete who trains hard to represent their country”?

Christina Vukicevic

Christina Vukicevic

I would say no, but am happy to listen to other opinions. No denying she is a beautiful woman and looks good in a bikini, but the only thing relevant to her sport in these photos is what she is sitting on.

Now review the photo of Tom. What does his pose say? Relaxed. Smiling. Missing a shirt. A young bloke who has signed up to play rugby and is, I am assuming, rightly proud of his physique.

Now don’t get me wrong, male athletes have also been known to, in my opinion, have had some inappropriate pictures published of them. And not just those on social media after a big night out.

Really? Is this necessary from a couple of French players. As compared to our very own pink rugby calendar…….

Dieux du stade calendar

Dieux du stade calendar

Pink Rugby Calendar back cover

Pink Rugby Calendar

 

So am I a hypocrite or do I hold double standards? I don’t think so.

Do I ‘like’ photos of naked or partially clad rugby boys? Yep.

Do I think that all of these pictures are appropriate for all situations? Nope.

Do I agree with the promotion of sport through these images? Maybe not, but we are now talking about the National Rugby Championship and one of their teams.

Is any publicity good publicity? No. But that is a whole other discussion.

I guess my point is that photographs such as those we are discussing can be ‘tastefully’ done, but in a lot of cases, for both male and female athletes, they become all about the objectification of their bodies. And, no matter the gender, this is not OK.

My other point is that if you have a problem with people promoting certain images then it should not matter if the subject is male or female. If you think that the picture of Tom Hill is inappropriate, why is the Oxford Women’s Rugby calendar OK?

Have I got my point across? Probably not. But the back ground to this story is that the Greater Sydney Rams have joined the new Australian NRC competition and they are promoting themselves the best way they can to get people talking with out, in my opinion, over stepping the bounds. Job done.

For those that are interested here is the list of twitter accounts for the NRC teams. In no particular order.

Queensland Country – @QLDCountry_NRC

Brisbane City – @BrisCity_NRC

Perth Spirit – @PerthSpirit

Melbourne Rising – @MelbourneRising

Greater Sydney Rams – @Rams_Rugby

Sydney Stars – @starsrugby

North Harbour Rays – @NorthHarbourRays

NSW Country Eagles – @CountryEagles

Canberra Vikings – Not yet, but @BrumbiesRugby is currently carrying the torch.

I follow them all but the Rams have certainly been the best in both promotion and interaction. And this is not just because of the picture of Mr Hill. (Although it has helped….)

Now, where was I? Oh yes…….. rugby……..

Adam Ashley Cooper in water

Adam Ashley Cooper

 

David Pocock taking his shirt off

David Pocock

 

 

You Might Also Like

3 Comments

  1. 1

    I didn’t know you make mudcake! Seriously though- I agree about the “appropriate vs inappropriate” photos of sportspersons. I loved the Pink Rugby calendar but the Dieux du stade calendar? Holy no-thank-you, Batman. Same goes for lingerie football. Those two are just soft porn.

    • 2

      That’s the phrase! Don’t get me started on the uniform ‘specifications’ for beach volley ball players…….

  2. 3

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>